Some American Civil War films

Something that I have not previously mentioned, I have had a life long interest in the American Civil War. To be accurate, Civil Wars in general, though that will probably be the subject of another post, not in this category. When I was young, there was a television series, called ‘The Gray Ghost’. This was imported from the USA, and concerned the exploits of a Confederate irregular unit, led by the real life officer, Major Mosby. The issues surrounding the causes of the war, States’ rights, Industrialisation and immigration in the North, and the issue of slavery, were not really addressed of course, and it was all about the action. I later read a lot about this war, and carried on the interest into adulthood. Like many others, I favoured the Confederacy, though naturally not from a racist standpoint, more from admiration of the tactical skills of their generals, and the bravery and resourcefulness of their armies, against insurmountable opposition. Despite the impact of this war, to the extent that even today, some Southern states display the Confederate flag in courthouses, and fly it above public buildings, comparatively few films have been made about it. I have made it my business to collect all those available on DVD, and the following are my choices from that small number. I appreciate that this is the very definition of a ‘niche interest’, and will forgive all those who take this no further.

Gods and Generals. This 2003 film is a ‘prequel’ to ‘Gettysburg’, made ten years earlier, and part of a trilogy, the third part of which has not yet been made, and is said to be ‘in production’ for next year. This film is superior to the first, and ends at exactly the correct time, for the previous film to pick up the events that followed. Concentrating on the short career of the Confederate general, Thomas Jackson, famously nicknamed ‘Stonewall’ by his men, and filmed on and around actual Civil War battlefields, with a huge cast of amateur enthusiasts, who re-enact the fierce fighting, in addition to the well-known leads. The overwhelming impression is one of complete authenticity, though violence, and portrayal of injury and death is restricted in intensity, to allow for a lower age certification. Stephen Lang turns in a memorable performance as the religious and troubled Jackson, a man whose skill as a military tactician might not have been as great as it was painted. There is also able support from a restrained Robert Duvall, as Robert. E. Lee, and Jeff Daniels, as the Union Colonel Chamberlain. It is when the battles are raging that this production comes into its own. Bull Run, Fredericksburg, and Chancellorsville, are all recreated with great care and skill, and the scope of the film, with a running time of well over three hours, allows every detail to be shown. This film, and the earlier Gettysburg, were panned by critics, who mainly attacked the clumsy beards worn by the actors, and also complained about the occasional long monologues. If you like war films on this scale, and have the remotest interest in those troubled times, you will not be disappointed. Here is one of the battle scenes. Completely authentic.

Ride with the Devil. By contrast, this 1999 film, directed by Ang Lee, eschews the huge battles and massed ranks of the more conventional Civil War films, to concentrate on an isolated aspect of the conflict. Missouri, in America’s mid-west, was a state divided against itself, as neighbours and former friends chose sides at the outbreak of hostilities. Here, there were no rules, no uniforms, and no mercy shown to the enemy. Armed bands of irregulars roamed the state, and crossed into Kansas, to pursue the causes of the sides that they had picked. The story concentrates on a band of Confederate sympathisers, and their exploits during a relatively short period. Historical accuracy is flawless, and period feel is so good, it often seems like a documentary that could have been made at the time, if such technology had existed then. The action, when it comes, is a series of frantic engagements, and uneven fire fights, though a lot of time is spent sitting out the weather, and avoiding capture. The main set piece of the film, a depiction of the real-life raid on the town of Lawrence, in Kansas, with the massacre that follows, is well portrayed, and convincing enough. Where the film scores is in how it handles the quiet moments, and the human impact of the war. Excellent performances, including an exceptional Tobey Maguire, lift this film far above what you might expect. This is not just for the Civil War enthusiast, as it works for lovers of film everywhere. Here is an intense scene, from the raid at Lawrence, Kansas.

Glory. In 1990, this film, made the year before, won three Oscars. It shows something of the gravity of this production, that a film about events in the American Civil War, should achieve this. The reason why is well-known, as this deals with the formation of the first Black regiment in the Union Army, to actually be allowed to fight in battle, the 54th Massachusetts Infantry. The first part of the film concentrates on the racism that was still widespread in the North, and the opposition to arming black troops. There are the scenes from the training camp, the difficulties experienced by the all-white officers, and the eventual move South, to fight in the campaign in Georgia, and South Carolina. The predominantly black cast gave the producers a great opportunity to recruit the best black actors in the USA. Denzel Washington, (winning an Oscar) Morgan Freeman, Andre Braugher, as an educated Bostonian, and many more. The white officers are well cast also, with Matthew Broderick superb in the starring role, and Cary Elwes solid, as his second in command. In the latter part of the film, the regiment is finally given the chance to fight, and the first battle scene, involving hand to hand fighting in woodland, is edge of the seat stuff. Later, they arrive at the siege of Fort Wagner, an almost impregnable Confederate position on the coast. Expected to take a place at the rear, Broderick’s character pleads to be allowed to lead the forthcoming assault, and is allowed to do so. The futile attack is brilliantly portrayed on film, and despite failing to capture the fort, and suffering terrible losses, the 54th earn the respect of their fellow soldiers, as well as a place in history. A moving war film, with an engrossing plot, good script, and a great cast. Here is an early scene, depicting the battle of Antietam.

The Horse Soldiers. This 1959 film is essentially a mainstream western, and a vehicle for the stars, John Wayne, and William Holden. Directed by the master of the western film, John Ford, it tells the true story of a famous Union raid, deep into enemy territory, in 1863; when almost 2,000 cavalry made the journey of over 200 miles to Newton Station, to destroy the railroad connection to Vicksburg. As this is very much a Hollywood action film, some liberties are taken. Holden plays the part of an Army doctor, constantly at loggerheads with Wayne’s character, and there is a female interest, in the shape of a Southern belle, and would-be spy, played by Constance Towers. All this froth aside, the film actually manages to give an exciting and accurate portrayal of these events during the Civil War, as well as allowing the Confederates encountered, to be shown as brave and dignified opponents. Although it tries to be more of a cowboy film, than a serious film about an actual battle, it strangely succeeds in ending up as both. Two memorable set pieces involve the students from a Confederate Military Academy, attempting to stop the Union column, and the Rebel attack at Newton Station, as ragged troops arrive by train, to mount a forlorn charge. Surprisingly good. This is the memorable scene, when Confederate cadets are mobilised against the Union troops.

The Red Badge of Courage. This film is from 1951, directed by John Huston, and filmed in black and white. Based on the classic short novel by Stephen Crane, the film is also unusually short, running for only 69 minutes, a result of unforgiveable cutting by the studio. It also famously suffers from obvious continuity errors, and the potentially disastrous casting of Audie Murphy in the lead role. Murphy was the most decorated soldier in the US Army in World War Two, and used this fame to launch an acting career in Hollywood. Luckily, he suits this role, of the boastful, untried soldier, about to take part in his first action. The young man soon becomes terrified in battle, and runs away, hiding in shame. He later receives a small injury, and returns to his unit, wearing his ‘Red Badge of Courage’, the bandaged wound. At first he lies about his desertion, though later confesses, and redeems himself in the next attack. Despite all these shortcomings, this is a truly classic film. Huston uses extreme close ups to good effect, and the other actors in the cast, for the most part all relatively unknown, are a pleasure to watch. It says a lot about bravery and manhood, and of course, is anti-war in sentiment, and could just as easily be set during any conflict. Here is a clip of a battle scene, featuring most of the cast.

That is my somewhat selfish exploration of films set during the US Civil War. I hope that it prompts you to watch some of them, but I will be more than usually understanding, if you think that I am off the rails a bit, with this offering.


14 thoughts on “Some American Civil War films

  1. Pete, when I was going through your takes yesterday I seen this and thought of a real good small film that fits this category. ‘Pharaoh’s Army’. I would recommend it. I was a big fan of Chris Coopers early career. This film and ‘Watewan’ (not Civil War related) are my two favorites.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thanks, CB. I have that on DVD. i have collected every Civil War film available, (I think) including such hoots as the mini series soap opera ‘North and South’, with Patrick Swayze. Many of them are Region 1 imports from the US, which I have not been able to play since my all-region DVD player died. Funnily enough, I got a new one earlier this week, so will be setting it up soon. If you know any US Civil War films I might have missed, please suggest more. I have an account with Amazon US for Region 1 films, so I am ready to go!
      ‘Matewan’ is an excellent film. I saw that i the cinema in London, but don’t own the film.
      Best wishes, Pete.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Sounds like you have it covered. But if something comes to mind I’ll let you know. A friend of mine has a series he’s trying to pitch that takes place during the Civil War. Him and I have a script that was optioned by some hollywood types, what a bunch a bullshit that was except we made a few bucks. The option ran out so I have it back in my hands. feels better.
        Do you also indulge in books from that era? I’ve read some pretty good ones. Fiction and nonfiction. ‘Wildwood Boys’ by James Carlos Blake is a good read. I see you did a piece on Ken Burn’s doc. I haven’t read your take yet but I really like his work. Time for a revisit. I’ll stay in touch.

        Liked by 1 person

        1. I used to read a lot about the war, mostly non-fiction. (Including Shelby Foote’s huge history)
          Thanks for the suggestion, I will look it up. As for Burns’ documentary, I think it’s one of the best things I have ever seen.

          Liked by 1 person

          1. I was surprised to read so much antagonism about the Vietnam series from American bloggers and writers. Many of them served in that war of course, and think Burns betrayed their courage, and the death of their friends and comrades. When you have been in combat (I haven’t) it is hard to see that sacrifice as ‘pointless’, I get that.
            I grew up watching that war on the news. I was almost 14 in 1965, when it started to be widely reported on the BBC here, and 21 when the US left.
            I watched every report, all the documentaries, and looked at all the photos taken by the likes of McCullin and Page. I was also very political, and demonstrated against the war outside the US Embassy in London when I was 16. I was in the Young Communist League back then, so naturally opposed to a pointless imperialist war.
            Back to Burns’ series. I thought it worked so well. It used the ‘alternative’ views of some of those Americans involved, as well as seeing it from the viewpoint of the North Vietnamese and Vietcong soldiers too. It may well be the most balanced look at that war that has ever been filmed.
            Best wishes, Pete.

            Liked by 1 person

          2. Thanks for that Pete. Exactly what I was looking for. A personal touch. You stirred up all sorts of thoughts on my side.
            I came away with all sorts of emotions and new perspectives. The biggest one was Ho Chi Minh. I was totally ignorant of the kind of man he was. I agree with your summation sentence. Good stuff Pete.

            Liked by 1 person

  2. Gods and Generals: It took me two sittings, had I taken any notice of your advisory note on the length of the film I may have prepared better, but overall much enjoyed; especially once I gave into the historical side of the film and became interested. I now feel compelled to watch ‘Gettysburg’
    I’m also glad I now know why the good old boys named their car the General Lee.


    1. Thanks Eddy. If you liked this, then you will find Gettysburg more of the same, pretty much a ‘part 2’. If you get the proper version, it is also very long, so be warned (again). Martin Sheen replaces Robert Duvall as Robert.E.Lee. I will leave you to decide who does it better! There are lots more huge stick-on beards too, and a strange English soldier who is there observing. I didn’t realise that anyone didn’t know why that car was called General Lee, it had a Confederate flag painted on it! Maybe that’s just little old me, and my unusual interests? Check out when you get the chance, great film stuff. By the way, I have discovered how to reply to comments, rather than just adding new ones. Grown up blogging! Cheers mate, Pete.


      1. It’s odd what you know, and what you don’t; next time you need technical help with your computer I’m your man, and I’ll keep you in mind for any history questions that pop up, although I’ getting a fresh education with your film recommendations. Loving the false beards; hard not to be distracted sometimes.


  3. You make some good points Eddy, but as you rightly say, it is a Hollywood film, about an emotional event in American history, so it will obviously be overplayed! I like Ferris Bueller a lot, one of the few US comedies that I have any time for. ‘Ride with the Devil’ might be better for your taste. (Still Hollywood though!)


  4. Glory: Ok, a bit too Hollywood for me, a little over played and I couldn’t get Ferris Bueller out of my head, half expecting ‘Yellow’ playing the soundtrack.
    In saying that I did enjoy it 🙂


All comments welcome

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.